PhilSci Archive

To Save the Semantic View

Cunningham, Thomas (2008) To Save the Semantic View. In: [2009] Models and Simulations 3 (Charlottesville, Virginia; March 5-7, 2009).

WarningThere is a more recent version of this item available.
Download (179Kb) | Preview


    Proponents of the semantic approach to scientific theories (e.g. Giere 1988, 2004; French and Ladyman 1999) cite a number of critical publications as the origins of their positions. While the semantic view experienced widespread adoption by philosophers of science in the decades leading up to the 1990s, over the last two decades opposition to the view has increased demonstrably (e.g. Downes 1992; Cartwright et al. 1995). This growing disaffection suggests a two-part question: What exactly are the objections to the semantic view of scientific theories, and does the view have the conceptual resources to combat its opposition? This essay seeks to answer this question by performing a careful analysis of the positions of both advocates and adversaries of the semantic view. In addition, it is argued that to save the semantic view it is necessary to locate the source of the position’s problems and to retool its conceptual foundations. To ensure that the semantic approach has the resources to meet objections to it, exegetical analysis is performed, which demonstrates that the source of the view’s present-day woes lies in a subtle conflation contained in one seminal articulation of the view, van Fraassen’s The Scientific Image. It is argued that supplanting central aspects of that work with ideas from Suppes is the remedy needed to provide the semantic view with the necessary resources for becoming wholly defensible against its oppositions.

    Export/Citation:EndNote | BibTeX | Dublin Core | ASCII/Text Citation (Chicago) | HTML Citation | OpenURL
    Social Networking:

    Item Type: Conference or Workshop Item (UNSPECIFIED)
    Keywords: semantic view Suppes van Fraassen models
    Subjects: General Issues > Structure of Theories
    General Issues > Models and Idealization
    General Issues > History of Philosophy of Science
    General Issues > Theory/Observation
    General Issues > Experimentation
    Conferences and Volumes: [2009] Models and Simulations 3 (Charlottesville, Virginia; March 5-7, 2009)
    Depositing User: Thomas Cunningham
    Date Deposited: 24 Jan 2009
    Last Modified: 28 Aug 2013 09:58
    Item ID: 4429

    Available Versions of this Item

    Actions (login required)

    View Item

    Document Downloads