PhilSci Archive

Theory-laden experimentation

Schindler, Samuel (2012) Theory-laden experimentation. [Preprint]

PDF - Accepted Version
Download (437Kb) | Preview


    The thesis of theory-ladenness of observations, in its various guises, is widely considered as either ill-conceived or harmless to the rationality of science. The latter view rests partly on the work of the proponents of New Experimentalism who have argued, among other things, that experimental practices are efficient in guarding against any epistemological threat posed by theory-ladenness. In this paper I show that one can generate a thesis of theory-ladenness for experimental practices from an influential New Experimentalist account. The notion I introduce for this purpose is the concept of ‘theory-driven data reliability judgments’ (TDR), according to which theories which are sought to be tested with a particular set of data guide reliability judgments about those very same data. I provide various prominent historical examples (among others, the confirmation of Einstein’s prediction of star light bending in 1919) to show that TDRs are used by scientists to resolve data conflicts. I argue that the rationality of the practices which employ TDRs can be saved if the independent support of the theories driving TDRs is construed in a particular way.

    Export/Citation:EndNote | BibTeX | Dublin Core | ASCII/Text Citation (Chicago) | HTML Citation | OpenURL
    Social Networking:

    Item Type: Preprint
    Keywords: theory-ladenness, experiment, data conflicts, independent support, novelty, theoretical virtues, star light bending
    Subjects: General Issues > Experimentation
    General Issues > History of Philosophy of Science
    General Issues > History of Science Case Studies
    General Issues > Theory/Observation
    Depositing User: Samuel Schindler
    Date Deposited: 31 Jul 2012 21:41
    Last Modified: 24 Oct 2012 19:26
    Item ID: 9263
    Journal or Publication Title: Studies in History and Philosophy of Science

    Actions (login required)

    View Item

    Document Downloads