The Simulation Argument and the Self-Indication Assumption

Franceschi, Paul (2008) The Simulation Argument and the Self-Indication Assumption.

Full text available as:
PDF - Requires a viewer, such as Adobe Acrobat Reader or other PDF viewer.

Abstract

I present in this paper a line of refutation of the Simulation Argument. I recall first Bostrom's Simulation Argument. I draw then a comparison between the Emerald Case and the core analogy underlying the Simulation Argument. I also discuss the justification of the Self-Indication Assumption and its relationship with the Simulation Argument. I show lastly that the Simulation Argument is a disguised reformulation of an application of an extended form of the Self-Indication Assumption to the situation related to the Simulation Argument.

Keywords:Simulation argument, urn analogy, Self-Indication Assumption
Subjects:General Issues: Thought Experiments
ID Code:4137
Deposited By:Franceschi, Paul
Deposited On:25 July 2008