PhilSci Archive

An impossibility theorem for allocation aggregation

Wagner, Carl and Shattuck, Mark (2012) An impossibility theorem for allocation aggregation. [Preprint]

[img] Microsoft Word - Draft Version
Download (817Kb)

    Abstract

    In axiomatic approaches to expert opinion aggregation, so-called independence conditions have been ubiquitous. Such conditions dictate that the group value assigned to each decision variable should depend only on the values assigned by individuals to that variable, taking no account of values that they assign to other variables. This radically anti-holistic stricture on the synthesis of expert opinion severely limits the set of allowable aggregation methods. As we show, the limitations are particularly acute in the case of three or more variables which must be assigned nonnegative real values summing to a fixed positive real number s. For if the subset V of [0,s] comprising the allowable values of the variables satisfies the closure conditions (i)0 is an element of V ; (ii) if x is an element of V, then s-x is an element of V ; and (iii) if x and y are elements of V and x+y is an element of [0,s], then x+y is an element of V, then, if V is finite, which is always the case in practice, subjecting the aggregation of such s-allocations to an independence condition allows only for dictatorial or imposed (i.e., constant) aggregation.


    Export/Citation:EndNote | BibTeX | Dublin Core | ASCII/Text Citation (Chicago) | HTML Citation | OpenURL
    Social Networking:

    Item Type: Preprint
    Keywords: allocation aggregation, dictatorship, judgment aggregation, probability
    Subjects: Specific Sciences > Economics
    Depositing User: Carl Wagner
    Date Deposited: 04 Nov 2012 17:26
    Last Modified: 04 Nov 2012 17:26
    Item ID: 9382
    URI: http://philsci-archive.pitt.edu/id/eprint/9382

    Actions (login required)

    View Item

    Document Downloads