Smart, Benjamin T H (2015) Untangling the Epidemiologist's Potential Outcomes Approach to Causation. UNSPECIFIED.
Microsoft Word
The_Potential_Outcomes_Approach_-_philsci-archive.doc - Draft Version Download (152kB) |
Abstract
In this paper I untangle a recent debate in the philosophy of epidemiology, focusing in particular on the Potential Outcomes Approach (POA) to causation. As the POA strategy includes the quantification of ‘contrary-to-fact’ outcomes, it is unsurprising that it has been likened to the counterfactual analysis of causation briefly proposed by David Hume, and later developed by David Lewis. However, I contend that this has led to much confusion. Miguel Hernan and Sarah Taubman have recently argued (on the grounds that well-defined interventions are a necessary condition of measuring causal effects) that meaningful causal inferences cannot be drawn from obesity. This paper (and a number of others) prompted Alex Broadbent to criticise the POA conception of causation, accusing two of the four theses its proponents are (supposedly) committed to, of circularity and falsity. Here I scrutinise Broadbent’s claims, and suggest that a Popperian approach to causal inference in epidemiology diffuses both of his objections. However, I move on to argue that the POA’s commitment to granting only manipulable conditions causal-status, renders the position implausible as a conceptual analysis of causation (even when considered from just the epidemiologist’s perspective). That said, I conclude that the strategy the POA employs is an effective tool for effect-measurement in intervention-cases; if it is a conceptual analysis of causation at all, it must be restricted to the causal analysis of manipulable conditions. The POA’s failure to successfully demarcate causal from non-causal conditions simpliciter should therefore not be viewed as a serious threat.
Export/Citation: | EndNote | BibTeX | Dublin Core | ASCII/Text Citation (Chicago) | HTML Citation | OpenURL |
Social Networking: |
Item Type: | Other | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Creators: |
|
||||||
Keywords: | philosophy of medicine; philosophy of epidemiology; epidemiology; causation; counterfactuals; potential outcomes approach | ||||||
Subjects: | General Issues > Causation Specific Sciences > Medicine General Issues > Philosophers of Science |
||||||
Depositing User: | Dr Benjamin Smart | ||||||
Date Deposited: | 04 May 2015 14:54 | ||||||
Last Modified: | 04 May 2015 14:54 | ||||||
Item ID: | 11444 | ||||||
Subjects: | General Issues > Causation Specific Sciences > Medicine General Issues > Philosophers of Science |
||||||
Date: | 4 May 2015 | ||||||
URI: | https://philsci-archive.pitt.edu/id/eprint/11444 |
Monthly Views for the past 3 years
Monthly Downloads for the past 3 years
Plum Analytics
Actions (login required)
View Item |