Parker, Matthew W.
(2005)
Undecidable Longterm Behavior in Classical Physics: Foundations, Results, and Interpretation.
Abstract
The behavior of some systems is noncomputable in a precise new sense. One infamous problem is that of the stability of the solar system: Given the initial positions and velocities of several mutually gravitating bodies, will any eventually collide or be thrown off to infinity? Many have made vague suggestions that this and similar problems are undecidable: no finite procedure can reliably determine whether a given configuration will eventually prove unstable. But taken in the most natural way, this is trivial. The state of a system corresponds to a point in a continuous space, and virtually no set of points in space is strictly decidable. A new, more pragmatic concept is therefore introduced: a set is decidable up to measure zero (d.m.z.) if there is a procedure to decide whether a point is in that set and it only fails on some points that form a set of zero volume. This volume and probability: we can ignore a zerovolume set of states because the state of an arbitrary system almost certainly will not fall in that set. D.m.z. is also closer to the intuition of decidability than other notions in the literature, which are either less strict or apply only to special sets, like closed sets. Certain complicated sets are not d.m.z., most remarkably including the set of known stable orbits for planetary systems (the KAM tori). This suggests that the stability problem is indeed undecidable in the precise sense of d.m.z. Carefully extending decidability concepts from idealized models to actual systems, we see that even deterministic aspects of physical behavior can be undecidable in a clear and significant sense.
Item Type: 
Published Article or Volume

Creators: 

Keywords: 
Decidability, undecidability, dynamical systems, computable analysis, riddled basins, chaos, prediction, predictability, classical mechanics, physics, nearly integrable systems, simulation 
Subjects: 
Specific Sciences > Computation/Information > Classical Specific Sciences > Physics > Classical Physics Specific Sciences > Computation/Information Specific Sciences > Computer Science Specific Sciences > Physics 
Depositing User: 
Dr. Matthew Parker

Date Deposited: 
06 Jul 2017 17:58 
Last Modified: 
06 Jul 2017 17:58 
Item ID: 
13181 
Publisher: 
University of Chicago 
Official URL: 
https://search.proquest.com/pqdtglobal/docview/305... 
Subjects: 
Specific Sciences > Computation/Information > Classical Specific Sciences > Physics > Classical Physics Specific Sciences > Computation/Information Specific Sciences > Computer Science Specific Sciences > Physics 
Date: 
2005 
URI: 
https://philsciarchive.pitt.edu/id/eprint/13181 
Monthly Views for the past 3 years
Monthly Downloads for the past 3 years
Plum Analytics
Actions (login required)

View Item 