Brewer, Mark A. (2025) Transitioning Regulatory Kinds: Why Gender Transition Isn’t Analogous to ‘Race Transition’. [Preprint]
![[img]](https://philsci-archive.pitt.edu/style/images/fileicons/text.png) |
Text
mbtracgen.pdf Download (102kB) |
Abstract
This article offers a hybrid account of regulatory kinds and subjective fit to explain why the oft-invoked analogy between gender transition and so-called race transition fails both conceptually and normatively. The argument—recently circulated in popular commentary and endorsed by figures such as Richard Dawkins—suggests that if gender transition is legitimate on the basis of social construction, then racial transition should be equally so. Yet since racial transition is generally regarded as illegitimate, the analogy concludes that gender transition must be suspect. I argue that this inference rests on a category error: it conflates social construction with norm-governed intelligibility. Drawing on Brewer’s framework of regulatory kinds, I show that while both race and gender are socially constructed kinds, they are constituted by distinct clusters of norms regulating membership, uptake, and legitimacy. Gender, as a regulatory kind, includes historically evolving norms that accommodate agent-led transitions—reflecting the social uptake of authenticity, lived identity, and self-determination. Race, by contrast, embeds genealogical and cultural norms that systematically exclude such transitions from intelligibility. I supplement this account with Cosker-Rowland’s theory of subjective fit to illuminate why the phenomenological texture of gender identity has become central to normative recognition, whereas race has not. By clarifying the regulatory asymmetry between these kinds, the paper shows that the race/gender analogy fails not because the categories differ in kind or in construction, but because their underlying normative architectures license different forms of legitimate change. Recognizing this distinction is not merely a matter of conceptual hygiene, but a moral and political necessity.
| Export/Citation: | EndNote | BibTeX | Dublin Core | ASCII/Text Citation (Chicago) | HTML Citation | OpenURL |
| Social Networking: |
Monthly Views for the past 3 years
Monthly Downloads for the past 3 years
Plum Analytics
Actions (login required)
 |
View Item |
![[feed]](http://philsci-archive.pitt.edu/style/images/feed-icon-32x32.png){kind=icon}