Ceteris Paribus Laws

Reutlinger, Alexander and Schurz, Gerhard and Hüttemann, Andreas (2011) Ceteris Paribus Laws. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.

Preview

PDF (Ceteris Paribus Laws (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy))
Ceteris_Paribus_Laws_(Stanford_Encyclopedia_of_Philosophy).pdf - Published Version
Download (428kB)

Official URL: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/ceteris-paribus/

Abstract

Laws of nature take center stage in philosophy of science. Laws are usually believed to stand in a tight conceptual relation to many important key concepts such as causation, explanation, confirmation, determinism, counterfactuals etc. Traditionally, philosophers of science have focused on physical laws, which were taken to be at least true, universal statements that support counterfactual claims. But, although this claim about laws might be true with respect to physics, laws in the special sciences (such as biology, psychology, economics etc.) appear to have—maybe not surprisingly—different features than the laws of physics. Special science laws—for instance, the economic law “Under the condition of perfect competition, an increase of demand of a commodity leads to an increase of price, given that the quantity of the supplied commodity remains constant” and, in biology, Mendel's Laws—are usually taken to “have exceptions”, to be “non-universal” or “to be ceteris paribus laws”. How and whether the laws of physics and the laws of the special sciences differ is one of the crucial questions motivating the debate on ceteris paribus laws. Another major, controversial question concerns the determination of the precise meaning of “ceteris paribus”. Philosophers have attempted to explicate the meaning of ceteris paribus clauses in different ways. The question of meaning is connected to the problem of empirical content, i.e., the question whether ceteris paribus laws have non-trivial and empirically testable content. Since many philosophers have argued that ceteris paribus laws lack empirically testable content, this problem constitutes a major challenge to a theory of ceteris paribus laws.

Export/Citation:

Social Networking:

Share |

Item Type:

Published Article or Volume

Creators:

Creators	Email	ORCID
Reutlinger, Alexander	Alexander.Reutlinger@uni-koeln.de
Schurz, Gerhard	gerhard.schurz@phil-fak.uni-duesseldorf.de
Hüttemann, Andreas	ahuettem@uni-koeln.de