PhilSci Archive

Causation Beyond Manipulation: Revisiting the Butterfly “Effect”

Park, Brett (2025) Causation Beyond Manipulation: Revisiting the Butterfly “Effect”. [Preprint]

[img] Text
Causation_Beyond_Manipulation Revisiting the_Butterfly Effect.pdf

Download (1MB)

Abstract

Counterfactual dependence and probabilistic dependence are two criteria frequently used to analyze causation. ``Mere correlations'' - instances of probabilistic dependence and counterfactual independence - are a well-studied class of cases where these criteria diverge. In this essay, I provide an example of the opposite type of divergence: counterfactual dependence and probabilistic independence. The butterfly effect of chaos theory says that had a butterfly in the distant past not flapped its wings, but everything else was identical, it is possible (and indeed probable) that a present tornado would not have occurred. However, the math of chaos also tells us that whether or not the butterfly flaps its wings, the probability of the tornado is the same. I show how these two claims fit together, highlighting the distinct and unorthodox counterfactual origin of probabilistic independence in chaotic systems. Examining the case under different theories of causation, I find widespread disagreement about whether the butterfly's flap causes the tornado. I argue that this disagreement can be explained by an underlying semantic indeterminacy in our ordinary conception of causation. Rather than being exceptional, we should expect these types of relationships, and thus indeterminacies, to predominate in chaotic systems over long timescales.


Export/Citation: EndNote | BibTeX | Dublin Core | ASCII/Text Citation (Chicago) | HTML Citation | OpenURL
Social Networking:
Share |

Item Type: Preprint
Creators:
CreatorsEmailORCID
Park, Brett0009-0008-5432-2511
Keywords: Causation, Counterfactuals, Probability, Chaos Theory, Butterfly Effect
Subjects: General Issues > Scientific Metaphysics
General Issues > Causation
Specific Sciences > Complex Systems
Specific Sciences > Physics > Classical Physics
General Issues > Determinism/Indeterminism
Specific Sciences > Physics
Specific Sciences > Probability/Statistics
Specific Sciences > Physics > Statistical Mechanics/Thermodynamics
Depositing User: Mr Brett Park
Date Deposited: 03 Oct 2025 14:58
Last Modified: 03 Oct 2025 14:58
Item ID: 26826
Subjects: General Issues > Scientific Metaphysics
General Issues > Causation
Specific Sciences > Complex Systems
Specific Sciences > Physics > Classical Physics
General Issues > Determinism/Indeterminism
Specific Sciences > Physics
Specific Sciences > Probability/Statistics
Specific Sciences > Physics > Statistical Mechanics/Thermodynamics
Date: 2 October 2025
URI: https://philsci-archive.pitt.edu/id/eprint/26826

Monthly Views for the past 3 years

Monthly Downloads for the past 3 years

Plum Analytics

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item