Hartmann, Stephan and Sprenger, Jan (2008) Judgment Aggregation and the Problem of Tracking the Truth. [Preprint]

Preview

PDF JA_TT.pdf Download (281kB)

Abstract

The aggregation of consistent individual judgments on logically interconnected propositions into a collective judgment on those propositions has recently drawn much attention. Seemingly reasonable aggregation procedures, such as propositionwise majority voting, cannot ensure an equally consistent collective conclusion. The literature on judgment aggregation refers to that problem as the discursive dilemma. In this paper, we motivate that many groups do not only want to reach a factually right conclusion, but also want to correctly evaluate the reasons for that conclusion. In other words, we address the problem of tracking the true situation instead of merely selecting the right outcome. We set up a probabilistic model analogous to Bovens and Rabinowicz (2006) and compare several aggregation procedures by means of theoretical results, numerical simulations and practical considerations. Among them are the premise-based, the situation-based and the distance-based procedure. Our findings confirm the conjecture in Hartmann, Pigozzi and Sprenger (2008) that the premise-based procedure is a crude, but reliable and sometimes even optimal form of judgment aggregation.

---

Export/Citation:

EndNote | BibTeX | Dublin Core | ASCII/Text Citation (Chicago) | HTML Citation | OpenURL

Social Networking:

Share |

---

Item Type:	Preprint
Creators:	Creators Email ORCID Hartmann, Stephan s.hartmann@lmu.de 0000-0001-8676-2177 Sprenger, Jan
Keywords:	Collective decision theory; judgment aggregation; discursive dilemma
Subjects:	General Issues > Decision Theory General Issues > Confirmation/Induction Specific Sciences > Economics
Depositing User:	Jan Sprenger
Date Deposited:	27 May 2008
Last Modified:	12 Jul 2024 17:56
Item ID:	4042
Subjects:	General Issues > Decision Theory General Issues > Confirmation/Induction Specific Sciences > Economics
Date:	May 2008
URI:	https://philsci-archive.pitt.edu/id/eprint/4042

Available Versions of this Item

• Judgment Aggregation and the Problem of Tracking the Truth. (deposited 27 May 2008) [Currently Displayed]
  • Judgment Aggregation and the Problem of Tracking the Truth. (deposited 16 Jul 2009)
    • Judgment Aggregation and the Problem of Tracking the Truth. (deposited 29 Sep 2011 11:26)

Monthly Views for the past 3 years

Monthly Downloads for the past 3 years

Plum Analytics

Actions (login required)

View Item